diff --git a/web/src/pages/sources/oauth/OAuthSourceForm.ts b/web/src/pages/sources/oauth/OAuthSourceForm.ts
index e76a8a842..cc6cbcc12 100644
--- a/web/src/pages/sources/oauth/OAuthSourceForm.ts
+++ b/web/src/pages/sources/oauth/OAuthSourceForm.ts
@@ -124,16 +124,16 @@ export class OAuthSourceForm extends ModelForm<OAuthSource, string> {
                     <option value=${UserMatchingModeEnum.Identifier} ?selected=${this.instance?.userMatchingMode === UserMatchingModeEnum.Identifier}>
                         ${t`Link users on unique identifier`}
                     </option>
-                    <option value=${UserMatchingModeEnum.UsernameLink} ?selected=${this.instance?.userMatchingMode === UserMatchingModeEnum.UsernameLink}>
+                    <option value=${UserMatchingModeEnum.EmailLink} ?selected=${this.instance?.userMatchingMode === UserMatchingModeEnum.EmailLink}>
                         ${t`Link to a user with identical email address. Can have security implications when a source doesn't validate email addresses`}
                     </option>
-                    <option value=${UserMatchingModeEnum.UsernameDeny} ?selected=${this.instance?.userMatchingMode === UserMatchingModeEnum.UsernameDeny}>
+                    <option value=${UserMatchingModeEnum.EmailDeny} ?selected=${this.instance?.userMatchingMode === UserMatchingModeEnum.EmailDeny}>
                         ${t`Use the user's email address, but deny enrollment when the email address already exists.`}
                     </option>
-                    <option value=${UserMatchingModeEnum.EmailLink} ?selected=${this.instance?.userMatchingMode === UserMatchingModeEnum.EmailLink}>
+                    <option value=${UserMatchingModeEnum.UsernameLink} ?selected=${this.instance?.userMatchingMode === UserMatchingModeEnum.UsernameLink}>
                         ${t`Link to a user with identical username address. Can have security implications when a username is used with another source.`}
                     </option>
-                    <option value=${UserMatchingModeEnum.EmailDeny} ?selected=${this.instance?.userMatchingMode === UserMatchingModeEnum.EmailDeny}>
+                    <option value=${UserMatchingModeEnum.UsernameDeny} ?selected=${this.instance?.userMatchingMode === UserMatchingModeEnum.UsernameDeny}>
                         ${t`Use the user's username, but deny enrollment when the username already exists.`}
                     </option>
                 </select>
diff --git a/web/src/pages/sources/plex/PlexSourceForm.ts b/web/src/pages/sources/plex/PlexSourceForm.ts
index 726a6fb2e..cdd208666 100644
--- a/web/src/pages/sources/plex/PlexSourceForm.ts
+++ b/web/src/pages/sources/plex/PlexSourceForm.ts
@@ -146,16 +146,16 @@ export class PlexSourceForm extends ModelForm<PlexSource, string> {
                     <option value=${UserMatchingModeEnum.Identifier} ?selected=${this.instance?.userMatchingMode === UserMatchingModeEnum.Identifier}>
                         ${t`Link users on unique identifier`}
                     </option>
-                    <option value=${UserMatchingModeEnum.UsernameLink} ?selected=${this.instance?.userMatchingMode === UserMatchingModeEnum.UsernameLink}>
+                    <option value=${UserMatchingModeEnum.EmailLink} ?selected=${this.instance?.userMatchingMode === UserMatchingModeEnum.EmailLink}>
                         ${t`Link to a user with identical email address. Can have security implications when a source doesn't validate email addresses`}
                     </option>
-                    <option value=${UserMatchingModeEnum.UsernameDeny} ?selected=${this.instance?.userMatchingMode === UserMatchingModeEnum.UsernameDeny}>
+                    <option value=${UserMatchingModeEnum.EmailDeny} ?selected=${this.instance?.userMatchingMode === UserMatchingModeEnum.EmailDeny}>
                         ${t`Use the user's email address, but deny enrollment when the email address already exists.`}
                     </option>
-                    <option value=${UserMatchingModeEnum.EmailLink} ?selected=${this.instance?.userMatchingMode === UserMatchingModeEnum.EmailLink}>
+                    <option value=${UserMatchingModeEnum.UsernameLink} ?selected=${this.instance?.userMatchingMode === UserMatchingModeEnum.UsernameLink}>
                         ${t`Link to a user with identical username address. Can have security implications when a username is used with another source.`}
                     </option>
-                    <option value=${UserMatchingModeEnum.EmailDeny} ?selected=${this.instance?.userMatchingMode === UserMatchingModeEnum.EmailDeny}>
+                    <option value=${UserMatchingModeEnum.UsernameDeny} ?selected=${this.instance?.userMatchingMode === UserMatchingModeEnum.UsernameDeny}>
                         ${t`Use the user's username, but deny enrollment when the username already exists.`}
                     </option>
                 </select>